Cars and Bids vs. Bring a Trailer – Which one is Better

  • Nitesh
  • Calendar-icon Jan 09, 2024

Have you ever wondered which online car auction site is best for you, Cars and Bids or Bring a Trailer? Both are standout platforms that have completely changed the experience for car buyers and sellers positively. In today’s modern world, these auctioneer sites have emerged as the top contenders for car lovers everywhere. Cars and Bids is the go-to for contemporary and trendy vehicles, while Bring a Trailer is the hub for classic and vintage gems.

What sets them apart is not just their impressive selection of cars, but also the communities where car fans can connect and share their passion. Here, car lovers don’t just come to buy and sell; they come to share stories, exchange knowledge, and celebrate their shared passion for cars.

In this blog, we’re diving into the big showdown: Cars and Bids vs. Bring a Trailer. We’ll compare everything from how they got started to how easy they are to use, how much they charge, user experiences, and the special services they offer. Our goal? To help you figure out which site is the perfect fit for your car buying or selling needs. If you’re looking to find your dream car, understanding these two platforms will give you the inside track in the online car auction world.

Company Background and History

Bring a Trailer

Founded in 2007, Bring a Trailer has established itself as a significant player in the online car auction space. Known for its wide variety of listings, from classic to modern vehicles, BaT has built a reputation for attracting serious collectors. Its longevity in the market speaks to its success and reliability as one of the top car auction sites.

Cars and Bids

Established in 2020, Cars and Bids quickly gained attention in the online auction world. Focused primarily on latest cars, including many modified and unique vehicles, the platform has seen remarkable growth in a short period. Its rising popularity reflects a growing interest in a broader range of vehicles, including modern classics and modified cars.

Selling Process Comparison of Cars and Bids vs. Bring a Trailer

Let’s compare and contrast how these two leading platforms cater to sellers.

Cars and Bids

At Cars and Bids, the selling journey begins with a simple submission of your vehicle’s details. Once your car is reviewed and approved, you’ll be prompted to provide further information and photographs to showcase your vehicle effectively. The team collaborates with you to craft a compelling listing page that highlights your car’s unique features. They also consider your preferences for scheduling the listing, ensuring a smooth process.

Your car is then featured on the platform for a week, attracting potential buyers. After a successful auction, Cars and Bids facilitates the connection between you and the highest bidder to finalize the sale.

Bring a Trailer

Bring a Trailer (BaT) offers a more tailored approach to selling your vehicle. As a seller, you have the choice of three distinct packages: Classic, Plus, and Glove, each with different price points and services. The first step is to submit detailed information about your car, including professional-grade photographs. The submission process, leading up to the sale, can span up to two months, ensuring thorough preparation for the auction.

Once listed, your car goes through a 7-day auction process. BaT takes care of creating a custom-written listing for your vehicle, adding a professional touch. With a listing fee and additional options for photo services, BaT ensures that each vehicle gets the spotlight it deserves. The highest bidder at the end of the auction secures the deal, subject to a buyer’s fee.

In summary, Cars and Bids streamlines the selling process with its seller-friendly approach, zero listing fee for sellers, and quick listing timeframe. On the other hand, Bring a Trailer offers a more bespoke selling experience with a minimum $99 listing fees charged from the seller and a detailed preparation process for the auction.

Pricing and Fees

When comparing the pricing and fees of Cars and Bids vs Bring a Trailer, several key aspects stand out.

For Bring a Trailer (BaT), the selling process begins with the choice of one of three service levels

  1. Classic
  2. Plus
  3. White Glove

The Classic service charges a $99 listing fee and is the most basic option, whereas the Plus service includes professional photos and videos for $429. The White Glove service offers a tailored package, with the cost varying based on the services provided.

Once the auction is successful, BaT charges a buyer’s fee of 5% of the final sale price, with a minimum of $250 and capped at $5,000. The seller is responsible for the listing fee but does not incur any additional selling fees.

For Cars and Bids, the approach to pricing and fees is slightly different. The platform offers a more streamlined and cost-effective process for sellers. The listing on Cars and Bids is free for sellers, which can be a significant saving compared to BaT.

Cars and Bids charges a buyer’s fee subject to a commission of 4.5%, with the maximum fee set at $4,500. It also offers optional professional photography services for those who need their car photos from a professional photographer. The first is a one-hour photo session priced at $159, which includes 50 professionally edited images. The second, offering even greater value, is a two-hour photo session at $259, delivering 100 professionally edited images.

In summary, while both platforms charge buyers a percentage fee on the sale price, the key difference lies in the seller’s cost. Bring a Trailer offers tiered service options with varying fees, whereas Cars and Bids provides a free listing service for sellers. The choice between the two platforms may depend on the seller’s willingness to pay for additional services and the type of vehicle being sold.

Service Offerings and Vehicle Specialization

The service offerings of Cars and Bids and Bring a Trailer cater to distinct segments of the car enthusiast market.

Cars and Bids

This car auction site focuses on the modern enthusiast car market, ranging from the 1980s to the 2020s. This includes a wide variety of vehicles, from high-end sports cars like Ferrari F355 and Lamborghini Gallardo to more esoteric choices like a Dodge Dakota Convertible or a Mercury Capri XR2. The platform has a special emphasis on modified RX7s, appealing to those who appreciate custom enhancements. Cars and Bids are inclusive of all vehicles that are exciting, fun, or interesting, as long as they’re from the modern era. This approach makes it a haven for enthusiasts of contemporary cars that span a broad spectrum of styles and preferences.

The application process for Cars and Bids is straightforward and less demanding compared to its counterpart. It begins with basic inquiries about the vehicle’s VIN, model, mileage, unique features, and selling location, followed by requests for photos, title status, and the option to set a reserve price. This simplicity is designed to make the listing process accessible and hassle-free for sellers.

Bring a Trailer

On the other hand, BaT caters to buyers of vintage and classic vehicles. The platform is a go-to for those seeking to buy or sell esteemed brands like Porsche, BMW, Land Rover, Jaguar XKE Series, Ford, Bugatti, and Aston Martin DBS 6-Speed. It specializes in OEM and X7 vehicles, drawing in a specific group of classic car enthusiasts.

The submission process on Bring a Trailer is more comprehensive, delving into details like engine replacements, bodywork, and rust conditions. This thoroughness is integral to the platform’s ethos, as it underscores the importance of transparency and honesty in transactions. The community on Bring a Trailer plays a crucial role in maintaining this integrity, often acting as vigilant guardians who help uncover the truth about vehicles listed for auction.

Both Cars and Bids and Bring a Trailer have tailored their services to meet the needs of different segments within the car enthusiast community.

Platform Performance and Community

Bring a Trailer

BaT takes a more meticulous approach to its submission process. The time taken to approve a car for the final auction is somewhat longer, as it involves detailed checks, including professional photographs and car receipts. This thoroughness contributes to BaT’s impressive track record.

The platform boasts a community of 450K registered bidders, a significant figure that underlines its popularity and trust within the car enthusiast community. BaT has completed over 132K auctions, demonstrating its extensive experience in the online car auction market. Notably, the platform enjoys a high sell-through rate of 91%, indicating that the vast majority of vehicles listed on BaT successfully find new owners. Furthermore, it has 461K followers on social media.

Cars and Bids

Cars and Bids offers a contrasting yet equally effective approach. The platform streamlines the submission process, where sellers can quickly click pictures, upload them, and list their vehicles for sale. So, the selling time is faster here.

With over 475K members, Cars and Bids has built a large and growing community of car enthusiasts. The platform has successfully completed more than 17,000 auctions, showcasing its growing influence in the online car auction space. An impressive sell-through rate of over 85% indicates a strong demand for the vehicles listed on the site. Additionally, Cars and Bids’ significant social media following of 995K+ indicates a highly active and engaged online community.

User Experience and Customer Satisfaction

When it comes to user experience and customer satisfaction, both Cars and Bids and Bring a Trailer (BaT) stand out, albeit in different ways. Each platform is designed to offer a user-friendly interface.

Cars and Bids is known for its straightforward and streamlined approach. This platform is not overly rigid with its customers, offering a more flexible and responsive interaction. Users appreciate the simplicity and efficiency of the Cars and Bids process, particularly when it comes to setting reserve prices, which are reportedly more reasonable. The platform’s quick response times and less demanding requirements make it a user-friendly option, especially for those looking for a hassle-free selling experience.

On the other hand, Bring a Trailer takes a more detailed and thorough approach. The platform is known for its extensive vehicle data and robust community features, which are highly appealing to enthusiasts who value in-depth information and discussions about the vehicles. This attention to detail, while sometimes resulting in longer response times, is seen as beneficial in the long run. For instance, BaT’s policy of sometimes only accepting no-reserve auctions for certain cars, although it might take longer to get back to the seller, ensures a high-quality listing and auction experience.

Both platforms receive positive feedback from their users, with each catering to different needs and expectations. Cars and Bids is favored for its responsiveness and flexibility, while BaT is appreciated for its comprehensive approach and detailed listings. While both Cars and Bids and Bring a Trailer offer robust platforms, there are areas where user experience could be enhanced. This observation leads to an important consideration: what does it take to build an online car auction site that not only meets but exceeds these standards? If you’re contemplating this venture, understanding these nuances is crucial.

That is why we have come up with a game-changer for those who want to build car websites in the auction space. Our software for building cars website is designed to bridge the gaps identified in existing platforms. We prioritize features that are essential for a seamless, secure, and user-friendly auction experience. With our solution, users enjoy unparalleled payment safety, ensuring transactions are not just swift but also secure.

Moreover, we understand the significance of fair bidding practices. That’s why our software includes a transparent reserve price feature, allowing sellers to set realistic base prices. Additionally, it is the best car auction software with the functionality of proxy bidding. This feature is a boon for bidders who cannot be present online all the time, as it automatically bids up to a preset amount, ensuring they remain competitive in the auction.

Are you a Car Trader? Want to set up a Car Auction Website?

Ultimate Auction Car Software is ideal for you and would create an awesome website for you.

Professional Design with multiple filtersElevate Your Car Auction Experience with Ultimate Auction Theme

Dive into a masterful work of professional design where form and function come together naturally. Our program has a user-friendly interface that has been carefully designed by professionals, making it both aesthetically pleasing and easy to use. Elevate your interactions with the ideal balance of flair and efficiency, regardless of experience level, to set a new benchmark for user interface excellence.

Car Auction Software Images and Galleries
Auctioneer Software - Image Gallery for Building Cars Website

Easily Earn Buyer Commission
Buyer Commission - car Auction theme

Our platform promotes transparent transactions through a buyer premium system, a small fee on the final purchase price, fostering clarity and reliability in the auction process. We prioritize transparency, making buyer commissions integral for a trustworthy and seamless auction experience, empowering buyers to make informed decisions with confidence.

Collect Money automatically by debiting from the User’s credit card.
Automatic Debit - car Auction themeOur Automatic Debit of Bid ensures a seamless auction experience, automatically charging the winner’s credit card as the auction concludes. This innovative system ensures quick, secure transactions, eliminating the need for manual follow-ups and enhancing overall dependability and efficiency. Participants can focus on the excitement of winning without concerns about payment processing.

Let Seller submit their Vehicle.
Streamlined Vendor Seller Submission - car Auction themeOur Car Auction Theme offers a customizable, user-friendly listing submission form for vendors, ensuring a seamless process to quickly and accurately list cars. The form captures essential details, enhancing engagement with potential buyers and boosting auction success.

Ultimate Car Auction Software – Proxy Bid
Ultimate auctioneer software - build your dream car website


In summary, both Bring a Trailer and Cars and Bids offer unique benefits and experiences to their users. BaT stands out for its wide range of services, community engagement, and specialization in classic and collector vehicles. In contrast, Cars and Bids offers a more accessible, cost-effective platform, appealing particularly to enthusiasts of modern classics and modified cars.

Both platforms have proven their worth in the online car auction market, and your choice will ultimately depend on your specific needs and preferences. The online car auction world is constantly growing, opening doors for new websites that want to bring something special. If you’re thinking about joining this exciting market, our car auction software is here to help you get started. It’s tailor-made for the unique needs of this industry, giving you the right tools to stand out. With our software, stepping into the online car auction space is not just a dream, but a very achievable reality.

Get your own Auction Today!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Like this article? Spread the word

Related Post

From Passion to Profit : How Did Doug DeMuro Make His Money?

Ups and Downs of Bring a Trailer Auctions

Top 10 Best Car Auction Sites To Build Your Dream Car Website

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get your own Auction Today!

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Let’s Connect:

  • twitter-icon
  • youtube-icon
  • instagram-icon
Claim your 10% discount